Choosing the right pencil eyeliners can make all the difference in your daily makeup routine. Whether you’re going for a natural tightline, a bold cat-eye, or a sultry smoky look, a good eye pencil eyeliner should be easy to apply, richly pigmented, and long-wearing. With so many formulas out there—gel, waterproof, smudge-proof, or retractable—it can be tough to know which one will actually stay put and deliver the look you want. These picks are known for their smooth application, bold color, and long-lasting wear. No matter your budget or eye shape, one of these options is likely to become your new go-to.
List of the Best Eye Pencil Eyeliners
5. e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner
Looking for the best eye pencil eyeliner that’s smooth, long-wearing, and simple to use? The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner is a fan-favorite for a reason. Designed to deliver bold, defined lines without smudging or fading, this eyeliner glides on effortlessly and stays put all day long—whether you’re heading to work, out for a night, or even riding rollercoasters (seriously, reviewers tested it). With a creamy texture and no need to sharpen, it’s the kind of product that makes getting ready feel like a breeze. Plus, it’s 100% vegan and cruelty-free—beauty without compromise.
Key Features
- Retractable Design – No sharpening required, ever.
- Waterproof Formula – Stays put through sweat, humidity, and long days.
- Ultra-Pigmented Black – Delivers rich, bold color in a single stroke.
- Smooth & Creamy Texture – Glides on without tugging or skipping.
- Multi-Use Application – Great for lash line, waterline, or even as an eyeshadow base.
- Vegan & Cruelty-Free – Certified by PETA and Leaping Bunny.
What We Like
- Applies easily and smoothly, even for beginners.
- Lasts through busy days without smudging.
- Easy to remove with makeup remover—no scrubbing needed.
- Great for travel thanks to the twist-up, cap-secured design.
- Doesn’t require sharpening, so it’s always ready to go.
- Can create both sharp lines and smoky looks.
What We Don’t Like
- The tip can feel slightly thick for ultra-precise lines.
- No built-in cap holder—easy to misplace the cap.
Overall
The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner truly lives up to the name—no smudging, no fuss. Whether you’re creating an everyday look or going for something dramatic, this eyeliner delivers smooth, rich lines that last. With thousands of glowing reviews and a formula that’s kind to animals and skin alike, it’s easy to see why it ranks among the best eye pencil eyeliners available. If you want an eyeliner that does its job and then some, this one’s a smart pick.
4. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil
If you’re searching for the best eye pencil eyeliner that works beautifully on the waterline without smudging or fading, the Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil is made just for that. Designed specifically for tightlining and waterline application, this creamy matte black eyeliner glides on with ease, delivers intense color, and stays put for up to 24 hours. Whether you’re going for a natural enhancement or a sultry smoky look, this liner helps define your eyes without irritation or flaking.
Key Features
- Waterproof Formula – Built to last through humidity, sweat, and long days.
- Specifically for Waterline Use – Designed to stay in place on the inner rim of the eye.
- Creamy, Smooth Glide – Applies effortlessly without tugging or skipping.
- 24-Hour Wear – Enjoy long-lasting definition with no need for touch-ups.
- Smudge-Resistant & Transfer-Resistant – Keeps your eye look clean and sharp.
- Vegan & Cruelty-Free – No animal testing and no animal-derived ingredients.
What We Like
- Ideal for tightlining and adding depth to the lash line.
- Glides on smoothly with minimal effort—perfect even for sensitive eyes.
- Holds up well in heat, humidity, and long days.
- Removes easily with makeup remover—no scrubbing or raccoon eyes.
- Works beautifully for both subtle and dramatic looks.
What We Don’t Like
- The pencil needs sharpening, and without a built-in sharpener, it can be tricky.
- The tip may break if too much pressure is applied during application.
Overall
The Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil stands out as a must-have for anyone who wants long-lasting, smudge-proof definition that holds strong on the waterline. Whether you’re building a bold smoky eye or simply making your lashes appear fuller, this eyeliner delivers clean, intense lines that last all day. If you’re on the hunt for a reliable, creamy pencil that won’t budge, this is a top-tier pick in the world of best eye pencil eyeliners.
3. Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Pencil
Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil brings high-impact definition and staying power in one sleek, sharpenable pencil. Designed with rich gel pigment, this liner glides on smoothly and sets to a waterproof, smudge-resistant finish that can last up to 36 hours. Whether you’re heading to work, a concert, or simply need your look to stay fresh all day, this pencil helps you achieve a flawless, fade-free line from morning to night. It’s perfect for bold, dramatic eyes or subtle everyday looks—whatever your style.
Key Features
- 36-Hour Wear – Built to outlast your day with no need for mid-day touch-ups.
- Waterproof & Smudge-Resistant – Designed to stay put through sweat, tears, or humidity.
- Super Pigmented Gel Formula – Delivers intense color with a single swipe.
- Sharpenable Pencil – Allows for precise application and sharp lines every time.
- Soft and Glide-On Texture – Applies smoothly without tugging or dragging.
- Available in Multiple Shades – From classic black to bold colors like navy and amethyst.
What We Like
- Extremely long-lasting—perfect for long days or nights out.
- Smooth application works well even on sensitive eyes or the waterline.
- Versatile for both bold lines and smoky effects.
- Doesn’t smudge or flake once set.
- Great pigmentation—goes on rich and bold without needing layers.
What We Don’t Like
- Needs sharpening, which can waste some product if not careful.
- Soft formula may break if too much pressure is applied.
Overall
If you want a liner that can keep up with your lifestyle, the Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner Pencil is a go-to choice in the world of best eye pencil eyeliners. With bold color payoff, waterproof performance, and smooth application, this eyeliner is reliable, versatile, and well-loved by thousands of users. Whether you’re headed to work, the gym, or the stage, this liner is built to last.
2. Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl Eyeliner Pencil
For those who love a classic eyeliner that feels luxurious and looks effortlessly elegant, the Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl Eyeliner Pencil is a top contender among the best eye pencil eyeliners. With a creamy texture that glides on like silk, this pencil delivers rich color with precision. Whether you’re defining the lash line or blending for a smoky eye, it offers both control and versatility. The “Black Coffee” shade—a deep matte black-brown—adds definition without looking harsh, making it perfect for day-to-night wear.
Key Features
- Creamy, Smooth Formula – Soft texture glides on easily without tugging.
- Buildable & Blendable – Perfect for sharp lines or smudged smoky looks.
- Classic Pencil Style – Offers traditional control and easy sharpening.
- Long-Lasting Wear – Stays on for hours without flaking or fading.
- Matte Finish – Delivers a refined, non-shiny look.
- High-End Brand Quality – Trusted Lancôme craftsmanship for luxurious performance.
What We Like
- Incredibly soft and comfortable to apply, even for sensitive eyes.
- Great color payoff—especially for a subtle, natural liner look.
- Easy to blend for smoky or diffused styles.
- Excellent choice for mature skin or beginner-friendly application.
- Long pencil that lasts a long time with daily use.
What We Don’t Like
- Not waterproof—may smudge on oily lids or humid days.
- Requires regular sharpening, which can be less convenient.
Overall
The Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl Eyeliner Pencil delivers a soft, smooth application and timeless style. It’s a must-have for those who appreciate a classic eye pencil with rich pigment, reliable performance, and a luxurious feel. Whether you’re doing a precise cat eye or a smudgy daytime look, this pencil works beautifully. If you want to elevate your eye game with a refined, soft-focus finish, this is an eyeliner you’ll want in your beauty bag.
1. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil
If you’re looking for a no-fuss, long-lasting eyeliner that performs like a pro, the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil deserves a top spot in your makeup bag. With a smooth, pigmented formula and a waterproof finish, this pencil delivers intense color that truly stays put. Whether you want a bold cat-eye or a simple line for daily wear, this eyeliner glides on easily and holds strong through sweat, humidity, and time. Add in a built-in sharpener and smudger for versatile looks on the go—this liner makes getting ready effortless.
Key Features
- 24-Hour Wear – Stays vibrant and defined from morning to night.
- Waterproof & Smudge-Proof – Resists humidity, water, and wear.
- Smooth Application – Glides on easily with minimal pressure.
- Built-In Sharpener & Smudger – Perfect your look anytime, anywhere.
- Tested for Waterline Use – Gentle enough for inner eye application.
- Available in Multiple Finishes – Choose from matte or shimmer shades.
What We Like
- Goes on clean with bold color in one swipe.
- Doesn’t budge or transfer—even in heat or sweat.
- Built-in smudger allows for easy smoky eye effects.
- Sharpener hidden in the cap keeps the tip precise.
- Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
What We Don’t Like
- Tip can break if too much pressure is used during sharpening.
- May require makeup remover to fully clean off.
Overall
The Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil combines intense pigment, waterproof durability, and convenient features in one sleek tool. Whether you’re a makeup minimalist or a bold liner lover, this pencil adapts to your style and keeps your look intact all day long. With easy application and true smudge resistance, it’s a dependable pick in the world of best eye pencil eyeliners.
Buying Guides: What to Look for When Buying the Best Eye Pencil Eyeliner
Waterproof or Long-Wearing Formula
Choose a pencil that can hold up through humidity, sweat, and long hours. This is especially important for anyone with oily eyelids or watery eyes.
Smooth Application
A good eyeliner should glide on easily without tugging at your skin. Creamy textures are ideal for smooth application and easy blending.
Built-In Features
Some eyeliners include handy extras like built-in sharpeners and smudgers, which can save you time and help create different looks with one product.
Pigment & Finish
Look for rich, bold pigment that shows up on the first swipe. Matte finishes are great for classic looks, while shimmer can add a touch of glam.
Safe for Waterline
If you plan to line your waterline, make sure the pencil is ophthalmologist-tested and gentle enough for sensitive areas.
Sharpenable vs. Retractable
Retractable pencils offer convenience, while sharpenable ones allow for more precision. Decide which suits your routine better.
FAQs
Pencil eyeliners are easier to control and apply, especially for beginners. They’re also great for softer or smudged looks and are typically more versatile than liquids.
Yes, but make sure the product is labeled safe for waterline use. Many on this list, like the Urban Decay 24/7 and Revlon ColorStay, are designed for this purpose.
Use a waterproof or smudge-proof formula, and always apply to dry, clean skin. Setting with a matching eyeshadow or powder can also help.
It depends on your needs. Retractable liners are more convenient and mess-free, while sharpenable pencils allow for a sharper, more precise tip.
Use a gentle eye makeup remover or micellar water designed for waterproof products. Let the remover soak briefly before wiping.
Conclusion
A reliable eye pencil eyeliner should be more than just a makeup step—it should help you feel confident, polished, and ready for whatever the day brings. Whether you’re reaching for the ultra-bold pigment of Maybelline TattooStudio, the silky smoothness of Lancôme Le Crayon Khôl, or the all-day wear of Revlon ColorStay, each of the products we’ve reviewed offers something special.
The best eye pencil eyeliner for you is one that fits your routine, your style, and your comfort. With so many great options just a click away, you’re sure to find the perfect match that lines, defines, and stays put all day.
Leave a Reply